Friday, October 29, 2010

Use Machiavelli to argue against The Beatitudes

Machiavelli is a practical man who sees things in a way that will get the quickest results. He tells of some violent actions that must be taken in order for a Prince to get what he wants. Blessed are the merciful, for they will be shown mercy is not something a prince would do (line 5). A prince is more interested in gaining land and power to be merciful. If the people are not strong enough than they will be left behind or killed. A prince would not worry about killing anyone. In fact, some princes order the killings of many people just to gain power of a city or region. Blessed are those persecuted because of righteousness, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven, does not fit for a prince (line 8). If a person is not alive, then they are no help at all. A prince needs followers to fight and do his bidding. If they are persecuted, then people must not like them and will bring down a prince. The last thing a prince needs is a meek person. Meek people are easily pushed around and taken advantage of. A prince is a headstrong individual who is willing to do most things in order to gain the advantage and defeat his enemy. Overall, a person who follows the beatitudes during the time of Machiavelli will soon find himself living a very hard life if he is not yet dead. These people would be seen as too soft and readily taken over.

1 comment: